Need help finding wedding songs

My fiance and I are getting married in May 🥂 We have about 5 months, however, because I’m out of school until the beginning of next month I’ve been knocking a BUNCH of stuff out. One thing that I am super indecisive about is wedding songs.

I think I have processional and bride walk songs picked out (bless this broken road instrumental and you are the reason instrumental) but I am lost at the first dance.

We are looking for something country, but nothing I’m finding is really hitting the spot. I’ve been looking all week. I’ve probably spent 12 hours on my computer + phone looking. My fiance doesn’t like “mainstream” artists.

Does anyone have any recommendations? Artist recommendations as well.