Recommend me a game that will blow me away

I’m looking for a game to really get immersed in. I got into Elden Ring last year and since then went on a binge. Ive subsequently done a couple of souls likes (Lies of P, which is ok, and Lords of the Fallen, which I really loved).

I’m really struggling to think of new games to play. I’ve listed below games I’ve played and my thoughts on them, if that’s helpful.

Soulsborne Elden Ring - 10/10. Dark Souls 3 - 9.5 bloodborne - 9, Sekiro - 8.5, DS2 - 8, DS - haven’t finished, but not loving this…too clunky. demon souls - 8.5

Soulslikes Lords of the Fallen - 8.5 Lies of P - 7

Open world games: Arkham series - loved all of these AC odyssey - 8. Valhalla 6.5 RDR2 - 10 Cyberpunk - 7.5 Witcher 3 - 8 Dragons dogma 2 - 9

Horror:

Madison - 9 Visage - 7.5 Resident Evil - played them all, go from 7 to 9.5 Silent Hill 2 - 9 Alien Isolation - 9.5 Dead Space - 8 Callisto Protocol - 8.5 (sacrilege, I know)

There are others, but