Which is worse?

Been thinking about it.

There are two people and both are using ai.

Person 1.

They want to write a novel, they have notes and have AI make them a good outline to use for their plot. They write the story, no ai involved in the book.

Person 2.

They want to write a novel, they have notes and write a detailed outline. They have ai write the novel, no editing.

I've been thinking about this a lot lately. Ever since I made the video on rossdraws. It came to my head because rossdraws is a painter artist, he layers from a base and the OG rarely known. If someone wrote an outline with AI versus having it write it, who is "more wrong"?

I know some of you will say it's tainted no matter what but I've been thinking about this for 2 weeks now.

I feel like the ai outline is less wrong, because the labor of novel is still written by the person. Yet, how much of their outline did they write? Does it matter?

The guy who did the outline knew specifically what he wanted but it's all AI, unedited, it feels like maybe he knew what he wanted but I've seen books that forgot to remove excerpts that were published.